Herbie's Sports Collectibles logo design contest

Want to win a job like this?
This customer received 21 logo designs from 6 designers. They chose this logo design from geomateo as the winning design.
Join for free Find Design JobsLogo Design Brief
I am starting a sports cards and memorabilia shop. We will be selling stuff primarily on ebay early on, then will be opening a brick and mortar shop in the fall. I currently have another business called the Hungry Hippie, and we will be doing the logo for Herbie's Sports Collectibles as a spin off of the other brand. I have had a couple people work on this already, but wasn't fully satisfied with the results so I wanted to go on here and get the job done right. I've attached the current logo of the Hungry Hippie, as well as the unfinished attempt at a logo for Herbie's Sports Collectables. These can be used as reference for the new logo. The character from the Hungry Hippie logo is called Herbie, so the card shop brand will use the same character for the main part of the logo. I'd like to keep the vibe of the Hungry Hippie, but make something that has more of a vintage/retro 60's/70's sports feel to it. Would like to have the "Herbie's" text in the new logo in larger letters, and the "Sports Collectables" text as more secondary. Make the logo FUN. It's how we do things at the Hungry Hippie, and I want this brand to have the same feel. Feel free to message me with any questions and I'll respond as quickly as possible. Thanks for your help with this!!!
Target Market(s)
Local and online sports card enthusiasts
Industry/Entity Type
Sports collectibles
Logo Text
Herbie's Sports Collectibles
Logo styles of interest
Character Logo
Logo with illustration or character


Font styles to use
Other font styles liked:
- Use a font type similiar to the Hungry Hippie font text in our sister company logo. Would like a little more of a vintage feel though, possibly neon highlights or something like that
Look and feel
Each slider illustrates characteristics of the customer's brand and the style your logo design should communicate.
Elegant
Bold
Playful
Serious
Traditional
Modern
Personable
Professional
Feminine
Masculine
Colorful
Conservative
Economical
Upmarket
Requirements
Must have
- Vintage look. Brand cohesion with the Hungry Hippie brand (same character) Cool text for Herbie's Sports Collectables/I'd like a black/yellow/vintage color scheme similiar to the 60's/70's pittsburgh pirates uniforms
Nice to have
- Would like sports related items involved in the logo. The preliminary logo design had a football and graded card, as well as a baseball cap and jersey. Please use some similiar type of combination.