Logo Re-Design
Add your question or comments below
just rate or reject so we know what you are looking for,
thx
Apologies, DesignCrowd changed their format since last time I visited. I cannot find the reject option, only the rate option.
The design we are looking for should reflect exactly who we are as a brand. Automated, social sharing, promotion to targeted audiences.
just a suggestion that you don't rate designs 1 star in one category and 0 stars in all the other categories if you don't like something. i had an 81% rating which will now go down because of your harsh rating, which i've never had anyone be so harsh with. especially when designers are providing concepts free of charge to you.
TJ, unfortunately this new layout DesignCrowd has, lacks a bit when it comes to navigation/flow. When we go into view each design, it only provides us 1 overall star rating - not broken down into categories. If there would be upload abilities on this message I would have provided you a screenshot so you could see. In regards to the overall rating... We are a major brand, recently funded, expanding to a global market. This design was not at all consistent with our project details or requests. Did you thoroughly review the Summary prior to submitting your design? We spent much time with much detail spelling out exactly what we had hoped to achieve with this listing. I do appreciate your submission, but I cannot just hand out quality recognition/feedback. If every single design submitted received 3 to 5 stars, no matter the quality, what justice would that serve to this site or the designers that truly hit the nail on the head? You are a good designer, however this particular design was not at all in line with our objectives. I wish you best of luck with future projects.
One star is the equivalent of a 5% rating on a 100% scale. Do you think that is appropriate? 59% is a failing/poor grade in school. i'm not sure what you think is fair, but 5%....really? there is the option of giving up to 20 stars total in four categories. you gave me 1 star out of 20. you just click on the boxes next to the ratings to make them dark blue once you've clicked the feedback button. There are five boxes next to each category and they turn dark blue when you click on them. (I just ran a contest on Design Crowd, so I'm very familiar with the rating system, and it was very simple.)
Waiting for your precious feedback on my latest design
Is the logo on the test site in indication the a graphic is required to compliment text, or is it purely a typographic logo that is required?
1 - 8 of 8 comments